Saturday 14 March 2015

Counteracting alienation with technological arts and crafts

The alienating effects of modern technology have been discussed a lot during the past few centuries. Prominent thinkers such as Marx and Heidegger have pointed out how people get reduced into one-dimensional resources or pieces of machinery. Later on, grasping the real world has become increasingly difficult due to the ever-complexifying network of interface layers. I touched this topic a little bit in an earlier text of mine.

How to solve the problem? Discussion tends to bipolarize into quarrels between techno-utopians ("technological progress will automatically solve all the problems") and neo-luddites ("the problems are inherent in technology so we should avoid it altogether"). I looked for a more constructive view and found it in Albert Borgmann.

According to Borgmann, the problem is not in technology or consumption per se, but in the fact that we have given them the primary importance in our lives. To solve the problem, Borgmann proposes that we give the importance to something more worthwhile instead – something he calls "focal things and practices". His examples include music, gardening, running, and the culture of the table. Technological society would be there to protect these focalities instead of trying to make them obsolete.

In general, focal things and practices are something that are somehow able to reflect the whole human existence. Something where self-expression, excellence and deep meanings can be cultivated. Traditional arts and crafts often seem to fulfill the requirements, but Borgmann becomes skeptical whenever high technology gets involved. Computers or modern cars easily alienate the hands-on craftsperson with their blackboxed microelectronics.

Perhaps the most annoying part in Eric S. Raymond's "How To Become A Hacker" is the one titled "Points For Style". Raymond states there that an aspiring hacker should adopt certain non-computer activites such as language play, sci-fi fandom, martial arts and musical practice. This sounds to me like an enforcement of a rather narrow subcultural stereotype, but reading Borgmann made me realize an important point there: computer activities alone aren't enough even for computer hackers – they need to be complemented by something more focal.

Worlds drifting apart

So far so good: we should maintain a world of focal things supported by a world of high-tech things. The former is quite earthly, so everything that involves computing and such belongs to the latter. But what if these two worlds drift too far apart?

Borgmann believes that focal things can clarify technology. The contrast between focal and technological helps people put high-tech in proper roles and demand more tangibility from it. If the technology is material enough, its material aspects can be deepened by the materiality of the focal things. When dealing with information technology, however, Borgmann's idea starts losing relevance. Virtual worlds no longer speak a material language, so focal traditions no longer help grasp their black boxes. Technology becomes a detached, incomprehensible bubble of its own – a kind of "necessary evil" for those who put the focal world first.

In order to keep the two worlds anchored together, I suppose we need to build some islands between them. We need things and practices that are tangible and human enough to be earthed by "real" focal practices, but high-tech enough to speak the high-tech language.

Hacker culture provides one possible key. The principles of playful exploration and technological self-expression can be expanded to many other technologies besides computing. Even if "true focality" can't be reached, the hacker attitude at least counteracts passive alienation. Art and craft building on the assumed essence of a technology can be powerful in revealing the human-approachable dimensions of that technology.

How many hackers do we need?

I don't think it is necessary for every user of a complex technology to actively anchor it to reality. However, I do think everyone's social circle should include people who do. Assuming a a minimal Dunbar's number of 100, we can deduce that at least one percent of users of any given technology in any social group should be part of a "hacker culture" that anchors it.

Anchoring a technology requires a relationship deeper than what mere rational expertise provides. I would suggest that at least 10% of the users of a technology (preferrably a majority, however) should have a solid rational understanding of it, and at least 10% of these should be "hackers". A buffer of "casual experts" between superficial and deep users would also have some sociodynamical importance.

We also need to anchor those technologies that we don't use directly but which are used for producing the goods we consume. Since everyone eats food and wears clothes, every social circle needs to have some "gardening hackers" and "textile hackers" or something with a similar anchoring capacity. In a scenario where agriculture and textile industry are highly automated, some "automation hackers" may be needed as well.

Computing needs to be anchored from two sides – physical and logical. The physical aspect could be well supported by basic electronics craft or something like ham radio, while the logical side could be nurtured by programming-centered arts, maybe even by recreational mathematics.

The big picture

Sophisticated automation leaves people with increasing amounts of free time. Meanwhile, knowledge and control over technology are held by ever fewer. It is therefore quite reasonable to use the extra free time for activities that help keep technology in people's hands. A network of technological crafters may also provide alternative infrastructure that decreases dependence on the dominant machinery.

In an ideal world, people would be constantly aware of the skills and interests present in their various social circles. They would be ready to adopt new interests depending on which technologies need stronger anchoring. The society in general would support the growth and diversification of those groups that are too small or demographically too uniform.

At their best, technological arts would have a profound positive effect on how the majority experiences technology – even when practiced by only a few. They would inspire awe, appreciation and fascination in the masses but at the same time invite them to try to understand the technology.

This was my humble suggestion on a possible way how to counteract technological alienation. I hope I managed to be inspiring.

230 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 230 of 230
IK said...

Thanks since you are ready to share info with us. We're going to Typically just take satisfaction in all you've concluded in this article since I understand you happen to be rather worried about our.สล็อตวอเลท

BEFOR said...

Definitely useful publish! There's a great deal of info shown below which may support any compact company commence out which has a prosperous social networking campaign.สล็อตแตกง่าย

KIN said...

That's my incredibly very first time i consider shown below. I found loads of intriguing things as component of your respective weblog Particularly its dialogue. Inside the many thoughts on the posts, I suppose I'm not the 1 somebody acquiring all the fulfillment in this article maintain The great operateบา คา ร่า วอ เลท

JI said...

I like this details for the beautifully-researched information and exceptional wording. I purchased so connected to this product which i couldn’t end reading through through. I am amazed using your do The task and talent. Thank you lots.สล็อตเว็บใหญ่

RIW said...

I want to mention that This great site genuinely convinced me to make it transpire! Many thanks, Excellent submit.บา คา ร่า วอ เลท

ACV said...

I think that can be an instructive publish and it is quite useful and proficient. Therefore, I wish to thanks to the endeavours you've in-built scripting this educational post.สล็อต ฝาก-ถอน true wallet ไม่มี บัญชีธนาคาร

XXI said...

Many many thanks for finding some time to debate this, I sense strongly around it and definitely like Mastering far more on this topic. If at all attainable, Whilst you purchase practical experience, would you head updating your website with extra information and facts and specifics? It is extremely effective for me.บาคาร่าวอเลท

MAJAI said...

I unquestionably acquiring enjoyment with pretty much each individual hardly any minor bit of it. It really is an amazing Web page and nice share. I have to thank you. Terrific task! You Gentlemen do an incredible website, and also have some excellent contents. Maintain The nice complete.สล็อตทรูวอเลท

ton said...

This specific papers fabulous, and My spouse or spouse Which i take pleasure in Every single and every on the whole that you've got positioned into this. I’m self-confident that you will be developing a quite helpful location. I has actually been Moreover pleased. Wonderful conduct!สล็อตแตกง่าย

SING said...

What a fantabulous post this has been. In no way located this sort of important post. I am grateful to you personally and count on much more assortment of posts like these. Thanks considerably.สล็อตxo

RETURN said...

Hey what a superb post I've come on and rely on me I are literally seeking out for this related style of produce-up for before each week and scarcely arrived on this. Thanks greatly and will look For additional postings from you.เว็บสล็อต

scout said...

Great report Ton's of data to Browse...Excellent Male Retain Publishing and update to Persons..A lot of thanksเว็บสล็อตเว็บตรง

riw said...

Want to browse it,Expecting Extra new Update And that i By now Read through through your Modern Article its Amazing Many thanks.เว็บตรงสล็อต

SIRI said...

Wow I'm able to say this is yet another excellent putting up as envisioned of This website.Bookmarked This website page..เว็บ ตรง

KHACHI said...

Fantastic review, I'm positive you happen to be obtaining a my page outstanding response.เกมสล็อต

WIMON said...

I found that Online page definitely usefull which study is incredibly cirious, I ' ve below no instances found a weblog that desire a survey for this actions, pretty curious...สล็อต เว็บ ตรง

นิ้กกี้ said...

Thanks for really usefull details..สล็อตออนไลน์

bokober said...

อาหารทะเลภูเก็ต
อาหารพื้นเมืองภูเก็ต
ภูเก็ต

zeeshanking6 said...

An Indian Restaurant & Takeaway in Croydon. We serve a wide

range of delicious Asian & Indian food. We offer online

ordering and table booking.For reservation call 02036678566
adeenaskitchen.co.uk

Sulata Chatterjee said...

Hi There,

This is Sulata, I Really Like The Work & The Changes Being Provided In The Society.
I Really Like To Offer You To Link Your Website With Us And Vice Versa.
Do Visit Sulatastarot

Regards,
Sulatastarot

adeena kitchen said...

An Indian Restaurant & Takeaway in Croydon. We serve a wide range of delicious Asian & Indian food. We offer online ordering and table booking.For reservation call 02036678566
www.adeenaskitchen.co.uk

zeeshanking6 said...

Adeena's Kitchen, an Indian Restaurant & Takeaway in Croydon



Adeena's Kitchen is a Restaurant and Takeaway in Croydon. We serve popular and authentic Indian Cuisine to customers from all over the world.

The chef has 30 years of experience especially in Chicken and Mutton Curry, Biryani Dishes and Seafood - all with special herbs and ingredients of Indian cuisine. www.adeenaskitchen.co.uk/

Unknown said...

Excellent publish. I was examining this site repeatedly, And that i am amazed! Particularly handy information especially this page. Thanks and superior luck.เว็บสล็อต

Abhi said...

This blog in very informative for us

reactor said...

Wow. just bytebeat is an cool program.
Anyways guys.. ...i found with my old bytebeat...



t*(t>>12)





Actually here is my new one:


t|t>>t*22>>t>>7%+t<>2/7

But it does sound harmonic?

intellimindz.info said...

https://traininginmedavakkam.in/python-training-in-medavakkam/
Python Training in Medavakkam
Python Training in Medavakkam introduces students to the fundamental concepts of Computer Science. The goal of this, Python training is to develop a deep understanding of python for students. You will be able to work on your own in python with this Python Training in Medavakkam. We also provide 100% placement assistance for the students. We also provide Python certification for students who complete our Python Training in Medavakkam. +91 9655877677 / +91 9655877577

https://traininginmedavakkam.in/java-training-in-medavakkam/
Java Training in Medavakkam
IntelliMindz provides the best Java Training in Medavakkam. IntelliMindz is the No.1 institute for Java Training in Medavakkam for assured Placements. Start Learning our Java Course in Medavakkam and become a professional in Java. Contact us . +91 9655877677 / +91 9655877577 for more details.

shantanu said...

Great post, thanks for sharing valuable information, keep us posted Java Training in Pune

Java Classes in Pune

App Developers in Bangalore said...

Thank you very nice sharing.

Assignment helper said...

Worrying about your assignment and searching for an assignment helper near you. Stop your search, and connect with Global assignment expert for assignments and projects. Assignment Writer UK is known for delivering assignments with accuracy. Global Assignment Help has a team of experts with excellent knowledge in every subject. Whether you are a school-going student or a college student, we have solutions for both. Our assignment is easy to understand and knowledgeable. So connect with us for all your assignment requirements and we guarantee you to solve all your problems easily. Do visit our official website for more queries. And we are accessible 24/7 for your help.

Mobile App Development Company in Bangalore said...

Thank you very nice sharing.

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 230 of 230   Newer› Newest»